5th Sunday after Epiphany, Sermon by The Reverend Loree Reed

Luke 5: 1–11
May the words of my mouth and the meditations of our hearts be acceptable in thy sight, O Lord our strength and our Redeemer. Amen.

Did you ever hear the story of the man who died and went to heaven – only to find a massive wrought iron fence surrounding those celestial gardens and large mansions?  He walked and walked along that fence, looking for a way in, but every gate he passed was padlocked shut.  Finally, almost despairing, he cried out, “Unworthy!  Unworthy!”  From an upper window of one of the mansions a voice called out, “That’s the password.  Come on in.”  And, with that, a massive gate right beside him swung wide open . . . and the man walked straight through heaven’s gates.
This morning we heard two stories of men suddenly, unexpectedly, encountering the Holy.  And though those men’s backgrounds and credentials were different from each other’s, when they encountered the Holy they both cried out, “Unworthy!”  And for both of them, that honest reaction became their entrée, their invitation into the Lord’s service.
For the past two years, I have been honored to serve as one of the commissioners on the Diocesan Commission on Ministry.  Our task every year is to discern together with people who believe God might be calling them to serve as ordained priests or deacons — or else as lay leaders in the Church.  None of these people comes to this process lightly.  Nor do we.  Every one of us is aware that we hold their high hopes in our hands.  So every one of us prays – a lot – asking God to help us discern where he would use them.  Then we meet with these aspirants, as they are called at this point in the process, week after week in the fall.  We talk with them, we listen to their life stories and we read their spiritual autobiographies.  In all these encounters we form distinct impressions – of their spirituality, their capacity for ministry, their character – and, oh yes — their humility before God.  And though humility is not the primary quality we are looking for, it’s certain that its opposite — a sense of pride or entitlement — will quickly earn them negative votes.
We don’t know how long Jesus looked Simon Peter over before inviting him to become one of his disciples.  But if Jesus was looking for humility in this man, he certainly found it when Simon Peter finally glimpsed the enormous catch of fish he and his partners had hauled in after Jesus told them exactly where to cast their nets.  In that moment Simon Peter suddenly realizes that Jesus is not just some itinerant preacher who has borrowed his fishing boat to use it as a floating pulpit.  He is, instead, a deeply holy man.  And in his presence, Simon Peter realizes that he is anything but holy.
In reaction to this epiphany, Simon Peter falls to his knees before Jesus, confessing his unholiness, his sinful nature, and asking Jesus to depart from him.  Clearly, he thinks that someone like Jesus will want nothing to do with someone like him.  Beyond that, deep down, maybe he believes his sin is simply unforgiveable – and the stain of it would corrupt Jesus’ holy goodness.  We don’t know exactly what he was thinking.  But we do know that Jesus wasn’t looking at Simon Peter’s sin.  Instead, he has seen some untapped potential in the rough fisherman, a potential he believes is worth developing.  So in response to Peter’s confession – that he is unworthy of Jesus’ attention – Jesus replies, reassuringly, “Don’t be afraid, Peter.  From now on you will be catching people.”
And we all know how that turned out, because we’ve all read the end of the book.  Peter doesn’t come closer to Jesus so much as Jesus stays close to him.  Even when Peter fails him — spectacularly – Jesus shows him steadfast love and patience.  And as a consequence, ever so slowly, Peter l earns.  He learns by his mistakes.  He begins to grow.  And that’s the way it will work for us too.  In Mere Christianity, C. S. Lewis wrote,
. . . a Christian is not a (person) who never goes wrong, but a (person) who is enabled to repent and pick himself up and begin over again after each stumble – because the Christ–life is inside him, repairing him all the time, enabling him to repeat (in some small degree) the kind of voluntary death which Christ Himself carried out.
So in the end, just as Jesus had predicted, this rough fisherman finally does become the Church’s faith–filled leader, who now draws others in.  Not because he was worthy in himself, but because he allowed Christ’s love to work within him and guide him in the direction of who he could become.
I think there are a lot of us in Peter’s boat, so to speak.  We shy away from close contact with God because we can’t imagine God loving sinful, God–less us.  We know our sins, and we imagine He knows them too.  So we figure we won’t trouble him with our presence.  We won’t even try to get close to him.
But that is exactly the mystery of God – that he loves us despite ourselves.  Warts and all.  Failures and all.  Self–delusions and all.  What we have trouble understanding is the depth of his love for us, the depths of his patience and mercy.  What we have trouble understanding is that he’s not made of judgment.  He’s made of love and compassion and mercy.  And we, for our part, are not to set limits on his love, his compassion and his mercy.¹  We are not to imagine that because we are not pleasing to ourselves, we are not pleasing to God.²  We please him in ways we have yet to fathom.
So in the end, you see, it’s not about our worthiness at all.  Of course, we’re not worthy of such love and acceptance.  Nor is it a question of whether we love God.  It is, instead, about the humility to accept that God loves us – abundantly, beyond our wildest dreams.  And from that humble stance all else follows.  Gratitude.  Joy.  Peace.  Service.  Love for others.  It all begins — and ends — with God, the Alpha and the Omega.
And to Him we give the glory.
Amen.
¹ Thomas Merton, aas quoted in Connections, February 2022.
² ibid.
 
Return to Sermons Archived Sermons Home Page